Skip main navigation

Keystone Custom Homes Reviews

What Homeowners Have to Say About Keystone Custom Homes.

Keystone Custom Homes has a reputation for building quality new construction homes. Their satisfied homeowners give them an average rating of 3.3 stars for their beautiful floor plans and affordable upgrades, their skilled craftsmanship, and commitment to customer service on each house they build. You can read all of Keystone Custom Homes 39 homeowner reviews to learn why they are the right team to build your new home.

Keystone Custom Homes

has 3.3 out of 5 stars in All Areas

39 Reviews in All Areas

Ratings by Category

Overall 3.3

Quality 3.5

Trustworthiness 3.5

Value 3.5

Responsiveness 3

Customer Reviews

Keystone Custom Homes - Took very long time to start the construction which resulted

  • Salimovakonul M.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 30, 2022
  • Conowingo, MD

Took very long time to start the construction which resulted financial burden. But other than that our construction manager Gary was the greatest person to work with. He made the whole process smooth and stress free. He was listening to our concerns and was going beyond to make us happy.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hello Salimovakonul, thank you for providing a detailed review of your experience. We will make sure to pass this feedback along to Gary and wish you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 5

The Keystone employees that assisted my Wife, and I with our home purchase process hav been a step above helpful. David was assisting me with a matter the first two days after our purchase. James still continues to follow up, ensuring our satisfaction.

  • Robert W.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • May 17, 2022
  • Red Lion, PA

May God Please continue to Bless every associate with Keystone, and there Families.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Robert, thank you for your review! We will make sure to pass this along to all of the team members involved in your home build. Congratulations on your new Brentwood Traditional! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 5

Keystone Custom Homes - We love our house it’s great having keystone build our house.

  • Malick B.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 31, 2021
  • Frederick, MD

We love our house it’s great having keystone build our house. The best builder with a great team from start to the completion of our house

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Malick, thanks so much for your review! Wishing you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 5

Keystone Custom Homes - Great experience.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • October 27, 2021
  • Gettysburg, PA

Great experience. Got it done in a timely manner with everything considered

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Thanks so much for your review! Wishing you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 4

Quick response and resolve any issues that arise

  • Katelyn B.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • July 29, 2021
  • Lancaster, PA

Overall the builders team are great and help solved all the issues.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Katelyn, thank you for your feedback! We're thrilled to have you in the Keystone Family! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

Keystone Custom Homes - Easy to work with.

  • Daniel S.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • July 07, 2021
  • Aspers, PA

Easy to work with. Friendly staff. Answered questions in a timely manner

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Daniel, we appreciate your review! Thank you for highlighting your experience with our team - we will be sure to pass it along to them! Wishing you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

Keystone Custom Homes - This was an awesome experience.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 17, 2021
  • Manchester, PA

This was an awesome experience.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Thanks so much for your review! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 5

Well worth the wait

  • Mark S.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 10, 2022
  • Mount Airy, MD

The build process can be frustrating for any new home buyer. The quality of this product is superior and well worth the wait! Keystone’s staff is responsive and seems to be honest, trustworthy and very educated regarding the entire build process. Bravo!

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Mark, thank you for your feedback! We wish you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 4

Follow through on all issues was great.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 20, 2022
  • Lebanon, PA

Took along time but keystone was there side by side with from the beginning to the end.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hello, thank you for your review. We appreciate your patience through the home build process and wish you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

Great experience from Day 1

  • Deanna L.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 12, 2022
  • Lancaster, PA

Our experience to date with Keystone Custom Homes has been positive. From site selection, to design choices to construction and move-in, our team was attentive to our needs and quick to respond with any questions. Our construction manager, Chris T, was in constant communication throughout the build which made the process less stressful and more enjoyable.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Deanna, thank you for your review! We will make sure to pass this along to our Construction Team. Wishing you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

Great Construction Manager

  • Erica C.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • April 20, 2022
  • Frederick, MD

Jarrod was wonderful! He made sure we settled on time!

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Erica! We will pass this along to our team. Wishing you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 5

Responsiveness 4

House looks great took longer then expected!

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 08, 2022
  • Dauphin, PA

House turned out great but took almost a year and a half. Loan rates tripled by the time the house was done.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hello, we appreciate your feedback here and will communicate this to our team to improve our process for future customers! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

Customization

  • Devron C.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 10, 2021
  • North East, MD

Overall we had a great experience from beginning to end.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Thanks for your review, Devron! We hope you enjoy your home in Cool Springs! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

Beautiful, but Small Issues

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 15, 2022
  • Westminster, MD

Love my new home, but they keep coming back to fix things.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hello, thank you for your feedback! We are glad you are loving your new home and encourage you to stay in touch with our Warranty Team at warranty@keystonecustomhome.com regarding any outstanding issues! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 5

Responsiveness 1

Great options for building on our own lot.

  • Katrin M.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 07, 2021
  • Manchester, MD

Keystone has a great selection of home with so many options and the ability to customize the house to our needs and we’re able to build within our budget.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Katrin, thank you for your review! We wish you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 3

First Timers

  • Veronica B.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • October 05, 2022
  • York, PA

This was our first time having a home built and there were so many things we wish we knew prior to starting. With that said, we love our home! We were blessed to be one of the first to buy a lot in our development and benefited from incentives. This allowed us to build the home we really wanted. Our biggest complaint through the whole process was our “designer”. She was very unprofessional and messed up a lot of our plans. Thankfully we caught it and were able to get it corrected. Some of our personal choices we had to fight for because she messed them up, but again, they were corrected. I ...

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Veronica, thank you for this detailed feedback! We will pass this along to our team to continue to improve our communication with future customers through the Design process. Wishing you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 3

Value 3

Responsiveness 2

Keystone Custom Homes - I have owned the house since October, making it 5 months of being

  • Stephanie W.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • March 27, 2022
  • Stewartstown, PA

I have owned the house since October, making it 5 months of being in the house. The molding or plaster on the staircase is already separating so you can see a crack running up the steps. The sales rep David Wong made the experience less than pleasant. To make such a large purchase and for this to be my first home I knew it would be learning in progress but David conducted as though my questions or frustrations with being told major homebuilding issues was an issue. I would have had a better experience and a better memory of buying my first home and not have felt like I was rushed or treated ...

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Stephanie, please make sure to include this in your Punchlist Manager request for our one year warranty. The reason that we wait to address these items until a year is so the house has time to settle and endure all four seasons. We appreciate you sharing your experience and have passed it along to our management team so that we can improve for future homebuyers. ...

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

Keystone Custom Homes - The trades didn’t show an interest in providing a high quality

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • July 12, 2021
  • Landisville, PA

The trades didn’t show an interest in providing a high quality product. Certain trades were very sloppy and the workmanship showed. The cleaners didn’t do a good job at all cleaning and preparing the house for move in.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hello, thank you for providing this feedback. We have shared this with our team and will use it to improve our processes in the future! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 3


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 5

Value 3

Responsiveness 4

Volatile Support & Customer Service

  • Michael H.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 14, 2022
  • Lancaster, PA

Overall the experience was subpar. You have to be really proactive in getting their attention. The app they give you doesn't work at times - or its an excuse for people not to follow up with you. Would recommend you resort to emails and CC all the Keystone Contacts you have so at least there is some accountability to follow up. The best support we received was from Tracy our designer. Outside of that before you head into design and after during construction you have to be very proactive in getting questions answered or actions taken.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Michael, thank you for your review. We will make sure to pass along this app feedback to our team so we can continue to improve communication with our customers! Wishing you many happy years in your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 3

Responsiveness 3

They got the house built on schedule

  • Ryan E.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • April 05, 2022
  • Pottstown, PA

We picked out small workmanship issues that could have been avoided. Overall nice job

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Ryan, we appreciate your feedback and will use it to improve our processes in the future. Congratulations on your new home! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 3


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 3

Keystone Custom Homes - House was built on a timely manner.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • October 21, 2021
  • Manchester, PA

House was built on a timely manner.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Thank you for your review! We hope you enjoy your home in Rolling Meadows! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 2

Keystone

  • Richard S.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 31, 2022
  • Frederick, MD

The house looks nice. We moved on April 26, 2022, and as of today 8/31/22 most of the punch list items are still not complete. There has been almost zero follow up from Keystone. Once they received the money from the sale they have stop finishing the items on the punch list.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Richard, thank you for your review. We see that you’re still within the 1-year warranty period. Please make sure to enter all of your requests into Punchlist Manager so that our team can properly address them at your 11-month check-in. We purposefully wait until 11 months so that we can make sure to cover anything that might surface through all 4 seasons! ...

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 1

Good home - half built still though :)

  • Vanessa C.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 30, 2022
  • Frederick, MD

I’m almost certain that this review was sent on the date that our house was supposed to be finished because they haven’t even finished dry walling yet. We have had a rough experience getting responses on our key choices app. The first project manager quit within a week of starting and the second PM was super responsive until we did our inspection. Currently we are on 4 weeks past when drywall was supposed to go in because they can’t fix the needed items. I’m also disappointed with how different and limited some of the choices were. I know supply is a challenge that everyone is facing, but it ...

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 3

Value 4

Responsiveness 2

Great Home Built- Terrible Communication

  • Courtney S.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 26, 2021
  • Frederick, MD

Overall, we are happy with our home. There are a few things we needed to submit in to be fixed but Keystone has fixed all of those things. The communication on the otherhand was far and few in between. After a while, we felt like the experience wasn't as personalable and we had to reach out ourselves about significant issue we were concerned about. Talking to our neighborhood, it seems like everyone feels the same way.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hi Courtney, thanks so much for sharing your feedback! We will certainly take it back to our team to make improvements for the future. Happy to have you in the Keystone Family & wishing you many happy years in Kellerton! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 3

Value 3

Responsiveness 2

Average

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • June 08, 2021
  • Harrisburg, PA

Average experience. Had a number of issues which are still trying to be resolved. Quality lacking in a lot of areas, mainly finishing. Responsiveness was good to all questions raised. Experience was great the entire purchasing/selecting process. Once we moved in, that changed. That's when we started noticing all the finishing/craftsmanship issues.

Keystone Custom Homes responded:
Hello, we appreciate this feedback. Thank you for highlighting your experience with the selection and purchasing process! Our Customer Care Team is dedicated to addressing your concerns. Please stay in direct contact with them! keystonecustomhomes

Total Score 3


Quality 2

Trustworthiness 3

Value 3

Responsiveness 4

Narrow Reviews by Area

  • Baltimore, MD - Coming Soon!
  • Harrisburg, PA - Coming Soon!
  • Lancaster, PA - Coming Soon!
  • Philadelphia, PA - Coming Soon!