Skip main navigation

Mayberry Homes Reviews

What Homeowners Have to Say About Mayberry Homes.

Mayberry Homes has a reputation for building quality new construction homes. Their satisfied homeowners give them an average rating of 4.5 stars for their beautiful floor plans and affordable upgrades, their skilled craftsmanship, and commitment to customer service on each house they build. You can read all of Mayberry Homes 46 homeowner reviews to learn why they are the right team to build your new home.

Mayberry Homes

has 4.5 out of 5 stars in All Areas

46 Reviews in All Areas

Ratings by Category

Overall 4.5

Quality 4.5

Trustworthiness 4.6

Value 4.5

Responsiveness 4.3

Customer Reviews

Great Choice and Style Homes

  • Erik F.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • February 09, 2023
  • Saginaw, MI

Process was overall great! Mayberry Homes did take great care into helping us make decisions and the building process was super smooth and went quicker than expected. I do wish even though we had taken over 3 hours at the initial planning meeting, there were several options or features we didn't discuss off the bat. You really need to go into that meeting knowing what's available out there and what you want so they can help you get exactly what you're looking for. While the house is fantastic, I am a perfectionist and I do notice several missed attention to detail spots. Things like some ...

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 5

Mayberry Homes - Great customer service from start to finish!

  • David B.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • March 15, 2022
  • DeWitt, MI

Great customer service from start to finish! Very responsive and accomodating. Overall excellent experience and would highly recommend!

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 5

Mayberry Homes - Easy to work with and responsive.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • December 28, 2021
  • Grand Ledge, MI

Easy to work with and responsive.

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

Done on time and within budget

  • Terry A.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 16, 2021
  • Haslett, MI

Very easy and thorough process from first meeting until move in

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

Mayberry Homes - Good people and good hause .

  • Rivaldo B.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • October 28, 2021
  • East Lansing, MI

Good people and good hause .

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 4

Mayberry Homes - Since we were moving from another state, Kelly was particularly

  • Russell M.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • January 04, 2022
  • DeWitt, MI

Since we were moving from another state, Kelly was particularly helpful in sending photos of the progress and returned all phone calls or emails promptly. She really helped make the buying process easy for us.

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 3

Management is super helpful.

  • Chirag M.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • April 19, 2022
  • DeWitt, MI

Mayberry Team and their architect were awesome. Great people to work with.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

Generally very happy with our experience

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • November 29, 2022
  • Okemos, MI

Mayberry was always professional and realistic. We were able to move in to our new home months before our initially stated timeline. We're generally very happy with our home and the continued service that Mayberry will offer to keep things that way. Our biggest regrets are allowing ourselves to be talked out of zoned heating and not enlarging the garage stalls and stock guest suite.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

Great Experience working with Mayberry

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • April 11, 2023
  • Okemos, MI

Had a great experience working with Mayberry with design, review and communication during construction phase. Kelly and Gary were very helpful. Only downside is Mayberry does not provide good options in the base home price and ended up upgrading many things in the home. This is when compared to other builders in the Lansing area like HDI.

Total Score 4


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 4

Value 3

Responsiveness 4

Ease of design and planning

  • Aimee W.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • February 23, 2022
  • Laingsburg, MI

Overall we are fairly happy with our house. Make sure you look at all of the details that you want. There are things that they are having to come back and fix, but I feel that happens with all construction

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

Make sure everything is completed before you close

  • Ronda M.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 04, 2021
  • Holt, MI

The sales team was terrific. Mark explained the entire process and worked alongside ame to discuss and make changes if needed. Solomon, the construction supervisor was amazing. He kept me informed of the progress and addressed any questions or concerns I had. He was very prompt in returning calls or texts. There are a few things that still need to be completed, redone, or replaced after closing and this is where the process falls off. The responsiveness I received during the sales and construction phases is not evident, which is disappointing. I realize the pandemic has slowed things down, ...

Total Score 4


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 2

Design process was great.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 03, 2021
  • East Lansing, MI

Once build got going, communicating was difficult. This problem was addressed. Things improved. Overall, we are happy with our home.

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 3

Very good overall experience

  • Craig P.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • January 24, 2023
  • Haslett, MI

Builder was very open to allowing us to customize our selections and letting us control decisions as we made considerations above builder grade material. All trades people met or exceeded our expectations with professionalism and communication with the exception of the framing crew. Every Mayberry team member we met and dealt with was courteous, prompt and realistic.

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 4

Value 3

Responsiveness 5

Key members oif the Mayberry Homes family

  • Jeffrey L.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 17, 2022
  • Charlotte, MI

A list of key Mayberry Homes personnel including names, title, email address, and phone numbers of those individuals that a buyer would likely deal with during the buying process would have been helpful.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 3

project manager

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • November 01, 2022
  • Grand Ledge, MI

We had communication issues w/ the project manager. We had several violations of the blueprints/contract. Some we were able to catch in time others we had to have Mayberry contractors correct them. One of them we just had to live with unfortunately. If they had only followed the blueprints and the contract those issues would of never existed.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 3

Value 4

Responsiveness 2

Plumbing And bird issues n vents

  • Karen M.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 10, 2021
  • East Lansing, MI

Mayberry and Bartlett Plumbing are not taking my plumbing issues seriously. The kitchen sink doesn’t drain. The water in kitchen sink bubbles up when the toilet is flushed. I have had birds in bathroom fan vents on and off for 12 weeks. Still waiting for screens to keep them out. Dirty nasty situation.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 3

Responsiveness 1

Great start with disappointing follow through

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 17, 2024
  • Howell, MI

Great on the sales side but the building process was not great.

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 2

Value 3

Responsiveness 3

Quality construction and energy efficiency

  • Mark K.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 03, 2021
  • Grand Ledge, MI

Be prepared to wait forever for follow up/communication on outstanding issues. Front line personnel were understanding and responsive were they could be.

Total Score 3


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 3

Value 3

Responsiveness 1

Mayberry Homes - 6 months into living in the home and some things are still left

  • Corey K.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 03, 2021
  • DeWitt, MI

6 months into living in the home and some things are still left incomplete. The beginning process is absolutely incredible including working with Mark. The building of our home was the biggest stress. Our wants in the home were kind of shoved to the side and given the answer "thats just how it is" when things were done incorrectly and we wanted them changed. Multiple details were ignored during the building process. It would take a drastic change in how they do things within the building process of our home for me to ever build with Mayberry again.

Total Score 3


Quality 2

Trustworthiness 2

Value 5

Responsiveness 3

Would not recommend Mayberry if you want what they say they are selling

  • Shawn Q.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 06, 2024
  • Grand Ledge, MI

Our home is beautiful. Exactly what we wanted, no. Are we happy, no. If we could reverse time and do it again would we use Mayberry, no.

Total Score 2


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 2

Value 3

Responsiveness 3

Disappointed

  • Donald V.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • December 14, 2021
  • Alto, MI

Started with a high degree of confidence based on model home quality. Very disappointed with the actual fit and finish of the finished product. Communication regarding buyer requirements to sub-contractors was poor, resulting in specifications not having been met

Mayberry Homes responded:
Dear Donald, thanks for sharing your feedback. We’re sorry your experience didn’t match your expectations. It was an uncommon instance and we'd like to learn more. We would like the opportunity to investigate your feedback further. Please would you contact me at info@mayberryhomes.com?

Total Score 1


Quality 2

Trustworthiness 3

Value 1

Responsiveness 1

Narrow Reviews by Area

  • Ann Arbor, MI - Coming soon!
  • Grand Rapids, MI - Coming soon!