Skip main navigation

Richmond American Homes Reviews in Jacksonville St. Augustine, FL

What Jacksonville St. Augustine Homeowners Have to Say About Richmond American Homes.

Read all 110 verified reviews from homeowners that built a new home with Richmond American Homes in the Jacksonville St. Augustine area. Jacksonville St. Augustine homeowners have rated Richmond American Homes an average 3.9 stars for the quality of their new homes and their commitment to customer service. You can read all of Richmond American Homes's reviews, to learn why their homeowners loved working with them, and why you should partner with them build your dream home.

Richmond American Homes

has 3.9 out of 5 stars in Jacksonville-St. Augustine Area

110 Reviews in Jacksonville-St. Augustine Area

Ratings by Category

Overall 3.9

Quality 3.6

Trustworthiness 3.8

Value 3.8

Responsiveness 3.7

Richmond American Homes in Jacksonville-St. Augustine Area

View Homes

Customer Reviews

Mostly good but glad we got a home inspection

  • Wayne Anthony L.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • October 10, 2024
  • St Augustine, FL

There were a lot of little things that needed addressed from our home inspection and walkthrough. The superintendent was super attentive to the issues that we experienced. The most concerning was the potential for shingle damage by wind. It was supposedly addressed but after Milton it looks like the area that they fixed had damage. Riding around the whole community, we saw no other homes with shingle damage so we are concerned of the quality of the roofers fixes that the home inspection brought out.

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

Great!

  • Ivan Jamil Garcia M.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 01, 2024
  • Saint Augustine, FL

Easy process and great personnel

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

Very good!

  • Diane Ganus R.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • December 13, 2023
  • Fernandina Beach, FL

Probably the easiest home buying experience I have ever had. Moved very fast and very professional. Love my new home.

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 3

Sales Representative - Five Stars!

  • Diana Lynn S.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 01, 2024
  • Yulee, FL

We had a great sales representative, Allison at Tributary. She was so easy to work with and responded to all of our questions. On the warranty side, we still have some outstanding items that need to be addressed. Hopefully they will be completed soon.

Total Score 5


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

Sales staff and construction superintendents were great.

  • Kaaron S.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • December 19, 2024
  • Jacksonville, FL

The paint contractor did a horrible job and cleaned his paint brushes in the kitchen sink! All the doors in the house have issues with paint splatters and don’t look like they were cleaned or sanded before painting. Upstairs bathroom has a piece on the bottom of the door coming off (can’t be replaced because it was seen at walk through! Puddling water between the houses.

Total Score 5


Quality 2

Trustworthiness 3

Value 3

Responsiveness 5

Not good for this man

  • ROBERT M.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • May 23, 2024
  • Orange Park, FL

We have numerous issues in this home all related to workmanship. I called the representative for home warranty and left a voicemail mail and no one responded.

Total Score 5


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 3

Value 3

Responsiveness 1

Cutting corners

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • July 05, 2024
  • St Augustine, FL

It seems that they rush to finish building the house. Hot water is lukewarm, garage is unpainted, no hand towel racks.

Richmond American Homes responded:
We truly wish you felt better about your experience, but we appreciate your feedback.

Total Score 5


Quality 1

Trustworthiness 2

Value 2

Responsiveness 1

Great experience, Would recommend

  • Haley Marie D.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 02, 2024
  • St Augustine, FL

Great experience, Would recommend

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 5

Responsiveness 5

Dawn is AMAZING

  • Stephanie W.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • January 17, 2025
  • Saint Augustine, FL

The house buying experience was what it was. Since closing, There has been issues with the house that arise such as a leaking toilet, some paint work, replacement of fridge doors, etc. I can call or text Dawn and let her know and she is on top of it. You don’t need to call her and remind her, you don’t need a long story but just the facts and she’s got it covered. It really has made me less anxious due to this being my first house. She’s a great asset to your company and hope she is recognized for her outstanding customer service.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 5

Responsiveness 5

salesperson that I worked with was outstanding,

  • Allan Stuart H.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 05, 2024
  • St Augustine, FL

Susan and Dylan were extremely helpful

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 5

The sales person was very helpful in every way I needed.

  • Maria R.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • November 29, 2024
  • Jacksonville, FL

Im very happy with my new home,

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

It was smooth transition, but builders need to come in and fix some pending items.

  • Chukwudi O.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • July 27, 2024
  • Jacksonville, FL

The whole process from start to finish was smooth and organized, and the quality and value of the house is very good. The builders are very tentative to my questions and was able to resolve any issues. If you are looking for good value and affordable mortage payment this builder is best bet.

Richmond American Homes responded:
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. If there are outstanding issues that need to be addressed, please reach out to me at jeff.jenkins@mdch.com.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 3

Value 5

Responsiveness 4

Surprised at closing

  • Patricia Lynn E.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • March 19, 2024
  • Fernandina Beach, FL

Was not given an estimate of closing costs for a cash sale. Was very surprised to learn a few days before closing that the costs were $7000.

Richmond American Homes responded:
Thank you for your feedback. We will share this information with our team to help refine our process in the future.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 5

Responsiveness 3

Overall Good House

  • Kristina W.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • August 10, 2024
  • Orange Park, FL

Scott was great to work with and was always responsive to our requests. He cared more about our experience than our real estate agent. Walkthrough items didn't get completed before our move in date and we are still working through some issues. Overall, it is a good house and we are happy. Quality is not as we anticipated since their models looked much better than any other local builders.

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

I was expecting a better

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • June 28, 2024
  • Yulee, FL

I was expecting better sad about

Richmond American Homes responded:
We truly wish you felt better about your experience, but we appreciate your feedback.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Value 4

Responsiveness 2

My experience has been slightly better than I expected.

  • Tommy Jordan G.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 18, 2024
  • Saint Augustine, FL

Everyone has been busy here, clearly taking on a lot of work. I have seen this before in new home construction. Things get overlooked, not done at all, or flat forgotten about. I am thankful for James, our warranty contact, as he has done a lot for us. We have a long way to go to be fully happy, but we will get there. Praise The Lord for everyone’s hard work here, before, during, and after the builds.

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 4

Value 3

Responsiveness 4

Failed Promises

  • Omolara Mariam N.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • March 14, 2024
  • Jacksonville, FL

It sounds frustrating that the promised gutter and other items weren't addressed before closing. I have contacted the superintendent to express my concerns and inquire about getting these issues resolved. Nothing has been done yet.

Richmond American Homes responded:
Hi, Omolara. I reached out to your local team and they let me know they’re in contact with you regarding your outstanding work request. They are your best point of contact if you have further questions. Thanks for giving us a chance to help!

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 3

Responsiveness 3

Quick and easy process to buy

  • Jason Wicker B.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • December 13, 2023
  • Saint Augustine, FL

Quick and easy experience for home purchase

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 3

Value 3

Responsiveness 3

Shamara W.

  • Shamara Nicole W.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • March 06, 2024
  • Jacksonville, FL

My only issue is repairs that promise to be fixed have not been fixed or partially fixed. And every home in my subdivision foundation isn’t showing like it is on my home. It seems like another piece of siding should go there. So unfortunately I’m not happy until this matter is taking care of.

Richmond American Homes responded:
We’re sorry to hear that, but we appreciate the opportunity to help. I’ve contacted management in your region.

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 1

Value 5

Responsiveness 1

MR X

  • Charles A.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • May 09, 2024
  • Saint Augustine, FL

There were punchlist items that were never completed prior to closing and no effort has been made to get them completed. Very unhappy with the service.

Richmond American Homes responded:
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. If there are outstanding issues that need to be addressed, please reach out to me at jeff.jenkins@mdch.com.

Total Score 4


Quality 2

Trustworthiness 3

Value 3

Responsiveness 1

Tough start, great ending. Good team of people!!

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 08, 2024
  • Jacksonville, FL

The beginning was rough. But Jeremy ( RH )and Steve (loan officer)Jennifer (loan processor)step in where my own realtor fell out. The team that does the walk though was amazing!! If not for tough start due to someone leaving and pass-off of clients & miscommunication. I would've marked higher for overall experience. I would recommend.

Richmond American Homes responded:
We appreciate you taking the time to respond. We will share this feedback with the team.

Total Score 3


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 4

Value 5

Responsiveness 4

Dawn

  • Anonymous
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 08, 2024
  • Saint Augustine, FL

She is awesome to work with. Extremely thorough, attentive, and follows through. She's communicative, and a problem solver.

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 4

Responsiveness 4

Attention to details

  • Craig B.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • July 06, 2024
  • Saint Augustine, FL

Nice home, nice lot. Craftsmanship could be a little better but not bad. Beware of an annual ($1,200) Silverleaf Master Owners Association due that is NOT included with the quarterly HOA dues. Evidently I am not the only one that was not told about this additional cost to live in this development according to a representative that collects these dues.

Richmond American Homes responded:
Thank you for letting us know. I’ll pass this info along to our team.

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Value 3

Responsiveness 3

Warranty issue with half bathroom/ vinyl flooring used - very poor quality

  • Ron Joseph B K.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • September 08, 2024
  • Saint Augustine, FL

Disappointed with having half bathroom floor dug up to repair issue with flange lodged in sewer piping. Vinyl floor material used in home is very poor qualify. Very disappointed with it.

Richmond American Homes responded:
Thank you for taking the time to leave a review. If there are outstanding issues that need to be addressed, please reach out to me at jeff.jenkins@mdch.com.

Total Score 3


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 4

Value 2

Responsiveness 4

Just "Ok" home buying experience

  • Tommie Gunville I.
  • Verified HomeBuyer
  • March 13, 2024
  • St Augustine, FL

The sales process was quick and easy. Overall the sales team was communicative and transparent. There were typical and atypical bumps and bruises along the way, most of which were resolved in an acceptable timeframe. We were forced into closing before the home was ready, leaving us with three pages of open items and a dirty home to move in to. Richmond and our supervisor Rob did work with us to resolve all of the issues after closing, and relatively quickly too. The warranty process was smooth and Jimmy has taken great care of us since we transitioned. Poor workmanship throughout the house ...

Richmond American Homes responded:
Your feedback is important to us. I’ve forwarded it to our team to help us better serve customers like you.

Total Score 3


Quality 2

Trustworthiness 3

Value 4

Responsiveness 4