Shea Homes-Trilogy Reviews

Stucco not cured properly on sunny side of house. Lots of cracking in the finish. Integral dark color finish installed. Where patches have been made, the color varies and photographs issues. Color missing in some locations. Stone veneer is sloped. Drywall nail heads are visible with some heads popping through. Tape joints are exposed. Cornerbead flanges are visible. 1/2" wide tiles installed from a 12x24 tile. Instead of recutting a larger tile to fit the space, a sliver was cut to make up the incorrectly cut tile. Sales team was great. Designer was extremely helpful. Superintendent finished the house on time. Expected more from a Shea home. ... More

The trades should adopt the saying “Do it right the first time”

Kirstie kept us informed during the building process of the delays we were incurring. We have been in the house two months and expected some snags in the new house. The response to correcting these snags has been mediocre in the sense of timeliness, the initiative on the part of the builder, and the accuracy of the corrective action. For example, a 220 Volt outlet was ordered in one specific part of the house. An additional outlet was actually wired to 220 V unbeknownst to us. We ruined several appliances in the troubleshooting process not to mention a potentially hazardous situation. The staff has been helpful but I can only assume they are overloaded with work to be done/corrected. Thermostat was also somehow miswired causing it to NOT shut off the Air Conditioner. It was apparent that finishing touches were rushed to make the 30 Sept closing deadline (delayed from original 30 April closing) to include no water softener installed yet, poorly finished landscaping of the yard, missing door hardware, and some smaller items. Still awaiting several snags to be fixed, corrected, replaced, or rectified after what has seemed a reasonable amount of time. ... More

Our home is still missing items. Other homes around us that are being completed have the items we are missing, yet we are constantly being told that we have to wait due to shortages. Do not accept your home if not 100% complete or you will be treated like a second rate human when it comes to getting the home completed as promised. We were so excited to buy our new home and especially it being a Shea Home, but have been treated like second rate humans after receiving our home. Each time we inquire about items that are supposed to be completed or replaced, we are told there are still back orders and we have to wait....except all the homes being built around us are getting the items. One would think that a company would take care of the people who trusted in them to keep their word. Sadly disappointed in our experience with Shea homes up to this point. ... More

Office staff is nice and friendly.

Love the community and the house. Wish that they had done a better job in inspecting and cleaning the house before delivery. It would have been a better representation of the quality of the builder and less follow up for me and my wife.

Love floorplan but this builder needs to hire better quality inspectors. Way too many things wrong. Plus the response time for corrections is very slow.

It was as expected for a new build

Hard to communicate with builder ….only text messages his phone mailbox always full. I understand delays but communication important! He was better toward end of construction _ mind you a year and half! I had one month appointment and still two issues not resolved? I’ve called twice - no call back? It’s been a month - I’ll have these two issues on the 5 month appointment- a few other things are needing attention as well! I get new homes always have issues - usually simple but would be nice for at least a call back.

Issues after delivery take too long to get resolved. We have 2 broken windows that were supposedly ordered before the house was finished. Been in house now 2 months, still have broken windows. Other issues same problem. Not responsive at all.

Poor workmanship. Many things were rushed, and it shows.

Our brand new fridge did not work, four rooms of our home only had primer on walls and was not painted until two months after we moved in. We had to move all furniture and walk hangings again. Many other issues. Very unhappy with how all of this was taken care of.

Sales staff easy to work with. Sub contractor slow to fix problems

We have found the Valor neighborhood in Idaho to be quite enjoyable overall. However, we have encountered some challenges with the quality of the finish work and the pre-inspection process. Upon moving in, we discovered several appliance issues that had not been addressed prior to our occupancy, despite Shea Homes' assurance of a complete home review. For the past three months, the oven has been non-functional, and the exterior paint on the house has been found to be faulty, requiring repainting, both have not been rectified. In addition to these issues, we have also observed subpar workmanship in other areas of the home. The concrete in the back porch was of poor quality, necessitating Shea Homes to apply epoxy as a remedy. Similarly, the finish on the garage floor is also below standard, and despite our requests, Shea Homes has not taken steps to rectify this matter. Furthermore, the wood frames on all the closets are coming apart, indicating further deficiencies in the construction. Outside the house, there have been safety concerns as well. The front walkway presented a trip hazard, resulting in multiple individuals tripping or falling. While a solution has been implemented, it is not up to par with the standards of the neighborhood and does not match the aesthetics of other homes in the area. Regrettably, our attempts to address these issues with Shea Homes have not yielded a satisfactory response. Although the warranty person assigned to our home is making efforts to rectify the situation, the time it is taking to resolve these matters is unacceptable. In conclusion, we are deeply disappointed with the lack of prompt and effective action from Shea Homes in addressing these concerns. We trust that Shea Homes will take our feedback seriously and work diligently to address these issues in a timely manner. ... More

I believe your overall experience depends on who you get as a field manager.

Pay attention to detail do not let them rush you through your walk-throughs because you will never get anything done it is horrible trying to buy a house and expecting it to be right and four months waiting to get it things repaired don’t let the smiles for you

The home is great. But but you really want to make Trilogy exceptional add more amenities. Restaurants, pools (only a 4lane 4ft deep pool), activities. A community of 1,500 homes in a small town needs to be inclusive. Without the Amenities needed you will never meet your potential. It can't be all about more homes. It has to be about Lifestyle. The clientele you deal with has many options and the ability to afford it.

Shea are amazing - they build a beautiful home and their staff are fantastic. However the landscape company are awful, the pool company are the worst at customer service and the ‘smart home’ and alarm company are impossible to deal with and do incredibly shoddy work.

Our sales associate was knowledgeable, helpful, and responsive! I was disappointed that we received no communication welcoming us or congratulation us after we closed. The project manager and warranty contact have been great! They have both been responsive and helpful. We are looking forward to enjoying our new home for many years!

This is a quality builder. Good sales person.

Nancy was very helpful. She showed us homes that met our needs. She answered any and all questions she could. If she wasn’t able to answer the phone when I called, she called back in a timely manner.

Love our home! Really do. From the base plans to the structural options, all are very well thought out. Zero quality issues. If you find fault - then it's an indication that you should have had a custom builder and the price that goes along with it. The only complaint we had was the multiple - and unclear - points of contact. We never really knew who could answer what when. Sales person basically drops off at contract signing. But then, with some options / changes, you need to go back to the sales person. Most selection are with a contract design firm. We never had a clear pricing list of the upgrades. e.g. arrived at AZ Tile to pick out our kitchen counter tops all to realize from AZ Tile there was an approved Shea list. Who knew!? Everyone seemed to have an assistant - so you'd get an email out of the blue stating 'sign this'. Why? Who are you? Full quarterly HOA fees were never fully explained - I will say in writing because I have zero record of it. Again - LOVE the end result. Just be ready to be very attentive along the way . . . and ask over and over again "what should I expect next?" "What should I do next?". ... More

Ongoing construction around me is difficult. The construction fence pushing people to walk thru my yard and smashing my plants is distressing. The loud music is annoying. Better design would include a solar tube in the dark master bath, counter garbage disposal button instead of under sink and thin grout lines (instead of 1/2inch white) in the floor. No real designer would put wide white grout in the floor.

Everything is great. Except the HOA.

I love my house but was disappointed at the rush for me to sign papers when I was away in Turkey. I notified Shea that I would be in Turkey and would sign when I return if everything was ready at that time. I was assured that was ok. I find out after I had to sign, while in Turkey at 2:30am, a few nights in a row, that upon my return my house price went down $100,000 and an incentive greater than I was given was now offered. Not pleased with that transpiring.