Skip main navigation

Shea Homes Reviews

What Real Homeowners Say About Shea Homes

With an average rating of 4.3 stars, Shea Homes is known for building quality new construction homes. Homebuyers rate their experience based on factors such as floor plans, affordable upgrades, quality craftsmanship, and customer service throughout the homebuilding process. We've collected feedback from 2168 verified homebuyers to give you an honest look at what it's like to build a new home with Shea Homes. Read their unedited reviews, feedback, and complaints to help you decide if Shea Homes is the right builder for your new home.

Shea Homes

has 4.3 out of 5 stars overall

2168 Reviews

Ratings by Category

Overall 4.3

Quality 4.1

Trustworthiness 4.3

Responsiveness 4.2

Customer Reviews

We done good...

  • Eric B.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • November 10, 2026
  • Paso Robles, CA

We picked the right house on the right lot and worked with a great group of people to create a wonderful place for Denise and I to live out what time we have. And all in such a great community. Shea was a good call for us... Eric and *****

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Great Experience

  • Donald W.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • November 10, 2026
  • Montgomery, TX

We love our new Shea home. From the time we first visited the community, the Shea people have been awesome. I would recommend Sheat to any prospective buyer,

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Some Frustrations...

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • November 09, 2026
  • Culpeper, VA

A Great Home and Local Team, But Corporate Processes Need Improvement Overall, we are very happy with our new home in Shea Homes' Three Oaks community. The quality of the materials is good, the home is well built, and the community itself is beautiful. We also had a very positive experience working with the local Shea Homes team. The sales staff, project manager, and warranty people were all great to work with, responsive, and helpful throughout the process. They deserve a lot of credit for making the local homebuilding experience a good one. Unfortunately, my experience dealing with Shea ...

Shea Homes responded:
Hello Kim, thank you for sharing your feedback and positive comments about the quality of your home and the experience of working with our team. Feedback like yours helps us keep improving. We truly hope you enjoy your home and Trilogy ThreeOaks for many years to come.

Total Score 3


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 3

Responsiveness 2

Brand new home

  • Michael H.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • November 05, 2026
  • Seaside, CA

The home , so far, has been a delight. We are enjoying it very much.

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Average

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • November 04, 2026
  • Fort Mill, SC

I had a customer home built by Shea in 2019. I assumed incorrectly I would have the same experience, new company is not the same. I was told items would be corrected that were only cleaned. Two other small issues were met with unacceptable responses. I mentioned that the area in the attic in front of the air handler was a mess, tiles and other items just haphazardly thrown around. Response was, "well I'm not going to clean it up and tiles guys are slobs. I expressed issue with shower door as magnet was so strong the entire frame pulled away when opening, in fact the frame was already ...

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Responsiveness 4

We are Loving our Home!

  • Albert C.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 30, 2026
  • OCALA, FL

We started our home buying process in December of 2025. Friends of ours bought a move-in ready home. It is beautiful. We decided to move to the same community and buy a Shea home. We chose to build new so we got everything we wanted.The sales rep and Orlando stayed in constant contact with us. We would drive up from ***** every month. We witnessed the process and were kept in the loop at all times. We have been here for two months now and could not be happier.We love the style of our home and the quality of it too. Our three dogs are crazy about it too.

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

A Pleasant Experience

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 27, 2026
  • Conroe, TX

Shea made it easy to buy the new build. There were a few issues with some of the building materials and the craftmanship but these were quickly remedied when pointed out. Shea receives kudos for their overall package to make home buying a pleasant experience.

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Excellent professional service

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 26, 2026
  • Marina, CA

Shea staff was very professional and helpful. We are very happy with the quality and comfort of our new home.

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Responsiveness, quality, and timeless

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 26, 2026
  • Manvel, TX

from the lot to the finished product and beyond This is my dream house

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Great

  • David C.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 25, 2026
  • Seaside, CA

Everyone was very professional, kind, helpful and very responsive.

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Great experience!

  • Sharron P.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 22, 2026
  • Peoria, AZ

From the moment I stepped into the Shea sales office, through the moment I was handed my keys, the whole process was outstanding. I don't think I could have had a better experience with a new home build. Everyone was, and still is, very friendly, polite, helpful and respectful. I definitely feel the quality and value of my house was worth the purchase price! I would definitely recommend a Shea home! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Very good experience with one major isuue.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 21, 2026
  • Magnolia, TX

Our experience was overall very good. However, our address was not registered properly with the ***** and after 3 months, we still are having issues with mail delivery.

Total Score 3


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 2

Quality Workmanship

  • Karin K.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 20, 2026
  • Littleton, CO

The PMs were so attentive to detail and delivering a quality product at every step. We especially appreciated their detailed eye prior to the punch list walk through. They had already fixed most everything and had an extra cleaning right before closing. So different from other builders!

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

I love every staff I worked with, they were all excellent.

  • Edward M.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 19, 2026
  • Queen Creek, AZ

The staff were very easy to get a hold of and they were all eager to help.

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

First time Shea buyer.

  • Kristan C.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 13, 2026
  • Castle Rock, CO

Shea has been great to work with. Their team is all about customer satisfaction. I'd definitely buy from them again.

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 4

Amazing service

  • Bryson M.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 06, 2026
  • Queen Creek, AZ

Our experience with our new build with Shea homes was absolutely amazing. From start to finish, Christa and Cindy provided top notch expertise and service. They were very knowledgeable and detail oriented. One of the best parts was their communication. They provided many ongoing updates which really helped us stay in the loop. Our home turned out amazing. We are very impressed with Shea homes!

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Initial buying was great.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 06, 2026
  • Culpeper, VA

Had a snafu with the post adders for our house.. Mainly the design adders.

Total Score 4


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Nice to have someone besides me build my home.

  • Robert R.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 06, 2026
  • Las Vegas, NV

I built my last two homes, so this was a new experience for me. Nice to have someone else do all the work for a change, but of course I couldn't choose all the upgrades I would have liked. great design, friendly people, knowledgable, but could use more cross training to widen their knowledge base. The window allotted for choosing extras was way too short, needed 2 or 3 meetings. some of the extras were much pricier than I could buy on my own, probably because you were double charging for labor. Example; the basic kitchen faucet already came with a labor charge, so upgrading it shouldn't ...

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Responsiveness 4

Overall satisfied with purchase with some areas for improvement

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 05, 2026
  • Marina, CA

We enjoy our new place - it is beautiful and mostly practical. A few things dinged the rating: * Water is very hard but we could not just install the water softener -- we had to replace the whole box which was almost $5K. * Window frame quality was not great and 2 windows had effectively broken levers -- this will be replaced by warranty but for a brand new place is disappointing. * Master bathroom has no reasonable place to hang towels (you have to install a bar on the glass wall and it is not trivial to find matching towel hangers). * One of the doors in the kitchen cabinet is oriented ...

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Responsiveness 3

Friendly and Professional, but things could move faster

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • October 05, 2026
  • Marina, CA

We love our home and overall happy with the quality. It's a beautiful home with thoughtful touches. Every person we have worked with have been amazingly friendly and professional. Unfortunately some issues are big enough to linger and tarnish the move in experience. Water heater, dryer, primary toilet did not work at move in, things we did not think to test during walk through. It took several weeks to get the dryer fixed and consistent hot water is still a daily guessing game. Most cosmetic issues were taken care of quickly. Some are still work in progress several months in. Apparently not ...

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 4

Responsiveness 3

Good experience.

  • Anonymous
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • September 30, 2026
  • Magnolia, TX

Nice house. It seems that some things were not finished in order for the builder to save money. Those expenses as a home buyer we are covering now.

Total Score 4


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

This is the second Shea home I have purchased and was very comfortable buying another Shea home due to my prior experience.

  • Catherine M.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • September 29, 2026
  • Mesa, AZ

Overall, the house has met my expectations. I did have some quality issues with the plumbing, electrical. However, the aftermarket warranty team is excellent and very prompt with a response and with the time the issues were fixed. I only have great things to say regarding the Shea Team.

Total Score 5


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Slightly disgruntled.

  • John S.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • September 28, 2026
  • OCALA, FL

In general, everything has been very good. The communication throughout has been excellent. There are a few annoying points that I wish that I had realized earlier. I lived a Shea home previously in another Trilogy community in California and the "extras" that were included in that home are glaringly missing in this one. 1) The garage opener light coming on automatically when you walk into the garage. 2) Being able to set an automatic close of the garage door after a set period of time. 3) Using the cheap plunger style sink stoppers that get stuck - in California we had the push down ...

Total Score 5


Quality 3

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Very pleased

  • Frank B.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • September 23, 2026
  • Conroe, TX

Oh my goodness, it has been a great experience, from start to finish. We had no idea the amount of information building from slab to Grass. The sales lady walked us through so many steps that needed decisions, from shapes colors just I the design alone. The construction superintendent was there to answer any questions during we had. And the follow up after we have moved in with any questions have been taken care of by there follow up warranty person. What else can I say, we are extremely satisfied we chose the right builder.

Total Score 5


Quality 5

Trustworthiness 5

Responsiveness 5

Very good experience

  • Andrea W.
  • Verified Homebuyer
  • September 23, 2026
  • Bonney Lake, WA

Overall, I am very happy with my home. The sales process was smooth and they were very accommodating - allowing me to have a contingency clause for selling my old home. Bryanne checked in with my frequently and sent me pictures of my home as it was being built because I moved from Illinois so I was not able to get out here very often. I wish there had been more choices in the design process, but I am still happy with what I chose. They did allow me some "customizations" such as my cabinet pulls which were only shown in brushed nickel but since they also came in bronze, they said they ...

Total Score 4


Quality 4

Trustworthiness 4

Responsiveness 4