- New homes
- Shea Homes
- Reviews
Shea Homes Reviews
saved to favorites!
To see all the homes you’ve saved, visit the My Favorites section of your account.
What Real Homeowners Say About Shea Homes
With an average rating of 4.3 stars, Shea Homes is known for building quality new construction homes. Homebuyers rate their experience based on factors such as floor plans, affordable upgrades, quality craftsmanship, and customer service throughout the homebuilding process. We've collected feedback from 2169 verified homebuyers to give you an honest look at what it's like to build a new home with Shea Homes. Read their unedited reviews, feedback, and complaints to help you decide if Shea Homes is the right builder for your new home.
Customer Reviews
Very good experience
- Andrea W.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 23, 2026
- Bonney Lake, WA
Overall, I am very happy with my home. The sales process was smooth and they were very accommodating - allowing me to have a contingency clause for selling my old home. Bryanne checked in with my frequently and sent me pictures of my home as it was being built because I moved from Illinois so I was not able to get out here very often. I wish there had been more choices in the design process, but I am still happy with what I chose. They did allow me some "customizations" such as my cabinet pulls which were only shown in brushed nickel but since they also came in bronze, they said they ...
Total Score 4
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 4
The installation of the irrigation system has caused me financial issues in the 60 days of ownership due to a leak with the RPZ outside and the tubing
- Sandra A.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 22, 2026
- Front Royal, VA
running inside the house. I originally pointed out a very green patch of grass where the RPZ is located and was told it was just condensation from the AC unit.
Shea Homes responded:
Sandra, thank you for the feedback. We are sorry for the frustration you experienced the first weeks in your new home. Our warranty team sent irrigation and plumbing contractors and was able to get the RPZ issue resolved. We have also committed to working with you regarding your water bill. Thank you for choosing Trilogy, we wish you many happy years in your new home.
Total Score 1
Quality 1
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 1
Love The Neighborhood
- Jeff C.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 18, 2026
- Kuna, ID
My experience however great, is overshadowed by a backyard that was installed very poorly and the time it is taking to rectify the problems (water is pooling because of the finish grading, unacceptable sod install, gaps, large divots that do not all the lawn to water evenly, I could go on). I found sprinklers buried under sod, installed at an angle making for poor coverage and pooling of water under plants that have led to dead or dying plants. There is a plan in place, it's just getting the plan executed. The community is very nice and we very pleased to be here. We made the right choice and ...
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 4
Disappointed in home and follow up
- Amy W.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 11, 2026
- Culpeper, VA
We are disappointed in the finish work in our house. Dry wall and ceiling waves. Very poor painting. No attention to detail. Painted over light switches. Barely applied one coat of paint. Molding on stairs and throughout poorly sanded and painted. Door handles were scratched. Doors were not hung properly and dragged. Our yard is a flooding mud pit and no one is doing anything about it. Issues are caused by poor drainage of the community and neighbor altering the pitch between houses. Multiple calls, emails and visits and still no remed after 6 weeks. . Hill behind our house has no grass and ...
Shea Homes responded:
Amy, thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts. We appreciate your feedback and regret to hear that your experience has not reflected the standard we strive to provide for our homeowners. The finish items in your home are actively being addressed, and Jason, the ThreeOaks General Manager, is involved in helping to see them through. The drainage situation requires coordination with the HOA, and we are currently working with all parties involved to move the process forward and reach a resolution as quickly as possible. We appreciate your patience and value you as a homeowner, thank ...
Total Score 3
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 2
Responsiveness 1
Terrible Experience
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 11, 2026
- Encinitas, CA
Terrible workmanship with very little accountability. All construction issues that were brought to Shea's attention during construction were ignored.
Shea Homes responded:
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and feedback, Allison. Our warranty manager Mark has been in contact with you to address your concerns regarding your warrantable items. If you have additional questions, please let us know by reaching out to our warranty customer service team. Thank you for choosing Shea Homes, we wish you many happy years in your new home.
Total Score 1
Quality 1
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 1
Worst New Home buying Experience, compared to our other 4 pervious new homes we have purchased.
- Guillermo M.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 08, 2026
- Magnolia, TX
No one from Shea was here to welcome us to our new home like other Shea buyers that have a welcoming committee. Outside Drive way Dry Mud, yard unkept, dead plants, spider webs entry way, dirty *****, Windows dirty. Inside floors dirty, Kitchen sink dirty, 1 of 4 keys worked, garage door opener did not work, 2 items with blue tape was not taken care of. This is only the tip of the Iceberg of issues that we continue to have including with our 1 month warranty. Can't wait to see what the other 2 warranties will be like.
Shea Homes responded:
Hi Guillermo, we want to thank you for sharing your experience. Our Houston warranty manager has confirmed that the warranty team has been in contact and working with you on your home’s warrantable items. We apologize that your closing experience was disappointing and Scott Villarreal, our sales manager, will be in contact to review your homebuying experience. Thank you.
Total Score 1
Quality 2
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 1
Home buying experience was great . Quality of workmanship and materials , there were a few light items wrong that were taken care of. Still very , very new in the home. Some more time will tell.
- Diane H.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 02, 2026
- Kuna, ID
Work with the buyer in the design built of home. I just had tile installed in my master bathroom shower floor, which I asked to have in my design and was denied. Now! You are offering tile installed in bathrooms. Paying so much for a home and ***** fees that should have been offered a long time ago. Shower pans are so cheap.
Total Score 4
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 5
**Do Not Trust Shea Homes With Your Closing**
- Karen B.
- Verified Homebuyer
- September 02, 2026
- Culpeper, VA
--- **★☆☆☆☆** **Do Not Trust Shea Homes With Your Closing** We recently purchased our home at ***** through Shea Homes, and what should have been an exciting milestone turned into a stressful, disorganized experience. First, our closing date was moved earlier without our authorization — shifting our very first mortgage payment from September up to August with no notice or discussion. That is not a small detail to spring on buyers, especially not on an elderly couple relying on a fixed budget. Second, the 4.99% mortgage rate that was advertised and used to sell us on this home turned out ...
Shea Homes responded:
We regret to hear that your financing experience did not meet your expectations. The Shea Mortgage team did identify an issue in the process and worked with you to resolve it. Our goal is always to provide a transparent and professional homebuying experience, and we appreciate the feedback as we continually work to improve our processes and communication. Thank you for choosing Trilogy ThreeOaks, and we wish you many happy years in your new home.
Total Score 2
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 1
Sub-par plumbing and sub-par support.
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 31, 2026
- Culpeper, VA
I have had to plunge several times. I had an flooding due to flushing flushable wipes. Shea Homes refused to fix the issue; it cost me $12K to fix. The toilets leave stains that require manual cleaning after use. Given the quality of the rest of the house, I find this plumbing implementation to be embarrassing to Shea Homes.
Shea Homes responded:
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We understand the plumbing issue was frustrating. We sent out a plumber who resolved the backup issue and assisted with clean up at no cost while determining this was a maintenance issue versus a construction issue. If you have any additional questions, please contact us at warranty@sheahomes.com. We appreciate you choosing Trilogy ThreeOaks and remain committed to supporting you as a valued homeowner.
Total Score 3
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 2
Responsiveness 5
Trustbuilder is a funny name for this survey
- Rick T.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 25, 2026
- Fort Mill, SC
All was okay - I only wish I was offered what other home owners were offered when they purchased their homes like the solar panels electric system that came with their homes and was not even offered when I purchased mine. I also would have liked a real front porch like the rest of the homes. My elevation is the only on without a real front porch to enjoy.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 5
I lost trust on Shea home purchase during the final steps of closing. The sales not transperent upfront and even the VP of sales not responding timely and even pushy on the customers and not helping much.
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 25, 2026
- Brentwood, CA
You have a great warrany service team. Very responsive, listens to the customers, explains what can be done and what can not be done. So appreciate this service with Shea homes.
Shea Homes responded:
Thank you for sharing your feedback. We are sorry to hear that your closing experience did not meet your expectations. Clear communication and responsiveness are important to us, and we appreciate you bringing your concerns to our attention. We are pleased to hear that our Warranty Customer Service team has been responsive and helpful in addressing your needs. Your feedback helps us continue improving the experience we provide to our homeowners. Thank you for choosing Shea Homes.
Total Score 3
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 3
Responsiveness 5
2026 Homebuyer
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 20, 2026
- Huntersville, NC
Our decision to purchase the house was heavily influenced by the floor plan and the quality of the finishes. During the construction process, the staff worked closely with us to answer questions and facilitate a final product that fit our needs and wants. We experienced a change in project manager, and some of the pending issues that were identified during site visits were not properly communicated. Despite these challenges, the company has taken the necessary steps to address the issues and find adequate solutions. In summary, we are very happy with the house and our decision to purchase ...
Total Score 4
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 4
2 Months into our new Shea Home....couldn't be happier.
- Scott P.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 18, 2026
- Littleton, CO
Purchasing, delivery, closing and warranty work so far have be wonderful.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
My best new home buying process yet
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 18, 2026
- Las Vegas, NV
I've purchased new homes in the past, but this was my first experience with Shea Homes. I've always been familiar with Shea and their reputation for quality, so I had high expectations going in. I'm happy to say that I've been very pleased with the entire experience and everything to date.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
5-stars
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 16, 2026
- Castle Rock, CO
5=stars
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Good not great.
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 16, 2026
- Culpeper, VA
Interior craftsmanship not the greatest. Unfinished areas remained dirty despite repeated attempts to have them cleaned.
Total Score 4
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 4
Horrible experience
- Erilyn J.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 15, 2026
- Conroe, TX
The response by Shea Homes to the leak of the dishwasher was horrible. Additionally, the lack of detail to the overall build of the house is unacceptable.
Shea Homes responded:
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience. Shea Homes values customer feedback and uses it to help improve the customer experience. Our Houston warranty manager, Brian, has advised that the dishwasher issue was addressed during the building process. If you have any questions or additional concerns, please contact our warranty customer service team at warranty@sheahomes.com. Thank you again for your feedback.
Total Score 1
Quality 1
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 1
No Worries
- Thomas H.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 13, 2026
- Bonney Lake, WA
The company and its representatives were available at every turn, whether it be in clarity of financial concerns, delivering on its promises quality upgrade decisions, or communicating clearly throughout the process. Our closing was smooth and easy, and the resulting move-in was not only ahead of schedule, but seamless.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
*****, Multiple Concerns
- Olette G.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 12, 2026
- Conroe, TX
My experience with my new construction home has been disappointing. I have not even been in the home for two months, yet I have already encountered several issues that have caused significant concern. At my one-month warranty walkthrough, the only issue I identified was the bathtub in the secondary bathroom. The tub did not appear to be new and appeared to have been resurfaced. That issue was reported and has been in the warranty process for approximately two months, and it is still not resolved. Since the one-month walkthrough, after actually living in the home, I have discovered ...
Shea Homes responded:
Thank you for taking the time to share your experience and feedback. Our warranty representative Daniel has been in contact with you to address your warrantable items. If you have additional questions, please let us know by reaching out to our warranty customer service team.
Total Score 3
Quality 2
Trustworthiness 2
Responsiveness 2
Shea made the transition from a resale to buying new construction a little difficult because I had to move twice.
- Ellen L.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 11, 2026
- Las Vegas, NV
Moving twice was very expensive for me and Shea did not have any houses that they offer for rentals we had to do it privately
Total Score 5
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Overall pleased
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 09, 2026
- Culpeper, VA
Open communication between builder and buyer from start to finish is key. Ensure all levels of departments are on the same page. Know what is occurring and what planned. My foreman was excellent. Knew what needed to be done, had great knowledge, experience and recommendations. A few items have been addressed and fixed. My warranty specialist is fantastic. Will see how things play during first year of warranty.
Total Score 4
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 4
Amazing home builder, amazing company to work with!
- Kristen S.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 08, 2026
- Manvel, TX
This house is beautiful and well made. Any concerns we've had have been resolved swiftly and efficiently. I trust that this builder has built a quality home that will last.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Shae homes 2 month experience.
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 08, 2026
- Ladera Ranch, CA
I am giving Shae a 5 star review because they have been on top of everything from pre home delivery to completing 1 month check in with a few more phased out over the year. We are very happy with the home & Art our warranty guy who helped with everything post close.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Extremely professional& organized
- Larry J.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 08, 2026
- Castle Rock, CO
The entire Shea team experience, beginning with the sales team through closing and into customer service, was highly professional, friendly and a rewarding experience.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Our Forever Home
- Jan R.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 08, 2026
- Front Royal, VA
Our experience has been very good. From having Troy as our Project Manager to Laura who is our warranty representative- they both have and are doing a stellar job. Our private inspector we hired to check the home before we closed was so impressed with the workmanship of the home. Said it was one of the best ever in his 15 years of experience. We are very pleased with the workmanship and any issues we might have had Laura took care of us promptly. We love living here.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Narrow Reviews by Area
Floorplan Name:
saved to favorites!
To see all the homes you’ve saved, visit the My Favorites section of your account.
Floorplan Name:
Home by [BUILDERNAME]
Builder Reviews Total Score in all areas
Here is a list of all the communities where this floor plan is available. Click to see pricing and community information.