- New homes
- Shea Homes
- Reviews
Shea Homes Reviews
saved to favorites!
To see all the homes you’ve saved, visit the My Favorites section of your account.
What Real Homeowners Say About Shea Homes
With an average rating of 4.3 stars, Shea Homes is known for building quality new construction homes. Homebuyers rate their experience based on factors such as floor plans, affordable upgrades, quality craftsmanship, and customer service throughout the homebuilding process. We've collected feedback from 2168 verified homebuyers to give you an honest look at what it's like to build a new home with Shea Homes. Read their unedited reviews, feedback, and complaints to help you decide if Shea Homes is the right builder for your new home.
Customer Reviews
Great building experience
- Jason G.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 06, 2026
- San Tan Valley, AZ
All Shea associates were great to work with! Sales, Design and Construction were all very professional and were fantastic to work with every step of the way. We are very happy with our home!
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Beautiful home, love it
- John C.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 05, 2026
- Las Vegas, NV
I'm very happy with my home; however, one suggestion: prior to moving in, I was given a list of the utility (gas, electric, cable etc) companies to contact, which I did. This list needs to be updated to include the ***** company. After living here a couple of months, I noticed a QR code on my solar box. I scanned it and it told me how to contact the solar company to get my service ACTIVATED. I contacted the ***** company, *****, and they said that Shea had not made my address available. I contacted my Shea rep and he told me that Shea was now working with Cooper and gave me Cooper's number. I ...
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Satisfying, enjoyable process.
- Richard V.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 05, 2026
- Front Royal, VA
Our sales manager, project manager, design manager and warranty manager are top notch. They've kept us well informed throughout the process, and we end up with exactly what we wanted and needed.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Leap of Faith
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 05, 2026
- Culpeper, VA
This was our first experience with an over 55 community. The process was a bit confusing at first, as we were in early and trying to make a decision and a purchase before the ***** was officially approved or models were available to see, and the contract incorporated documents that didn't exist. This has all since been straightened out. Everything regarding the construction and follow up, and really everything involving staff from Shea and its Blue Star partner have been great. We love our home and appreciate the quality of the construction very much. The ***** contractor staff have not ...
Total Score 4
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Love my house!
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 05, 2026
- Culpeper, VA
Love my house and the quality of the structure is excellent! Some of the finish work needs attention but I am working through it with my warranty specialist. The sod used in the yard is very disappointing and needs attention.
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 4
Efficient construction, with harsh visiting timeframe.
- Ronald Glenn H.
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 05, 2026
- Hollister, CA
We were very happy with our sales associate, Natalia. She made the whole process very easy for us. One of the reasons I gave my home buying experience Four stars is because there was only one lot that was an option to buy. In a sea of home lots, we were wound down to one lot because they wanted to build the houses on our street in succession. However, we did fall in love with ***** area and that is what swayed us to just settle for what they had available. The construction was very fast and efficient! My only complaint was having access to my house while it was under construction. We came ...
Total Score 4
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Somewhat frustrating prior to and during the first month of moving in.
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 05, 2026
- Hollister, CA
Overall, we love it here. Our experience was not perfect, however. To begin with, I was sold a corner lot based on the size of the lot AND the ***** of the hills. After I made an offer on my home and it was in escrow, my next door neighbors put in a gazego and arbor, basically blocking our lovely ***** of the hills. The ***** approved everything for them before we came along. We like these neighbors and they even decreased the approved height of the gazebo and moved the kitchen at their expense. However, since our experience, we have seen other similar intrusions permitted by the *****. ...
Total Score 4
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 4
Great experience. A few issues here and there but nothing serious
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- August 04, 2026
- Wickenburg, AZ
I really love living here on the ranch but wish I had spent a little more time here prior to our commitment on the house.
Total Score 4
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 5
Personnel are great
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 31, 2026
- Las Vegas, NV
Response to issues has been timely. The team is great.
Total Score 5
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
SoCal first time homebuyers
- John F.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 30, 2026
- San Marcos, CA
Have greatly enjoyed the experience as first time homebuyers!
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Quality and Kind
- Mark M.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 30, 2026
- Friendswood, TX
By default, they used high quality build practices, like spray foam insulation. Our sales representative was very responsive to questions we had and good to work with. The building manager was incredibly kind and patient and kept us looped in to everything going on with the home. He made us feel extremely comfortable with an unfamiliar process.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Many significant issues with major systems after moving in
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 30, 2026
- Hollister, CA
Quality control not what expected
Total Score 4
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 1
We Love our home!
- Sean H.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 29, 2026
- San Marcos, CA
Everything, the process, the construction, the staff
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Frustration
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 29, 2026
- Front Royal, VA
We moved into our new Shea home in mid-June, 2026. Shea personnel have been pleasant and generally responsive in correcting a number of punchlist issues in our home. However, we've had ongoing problems with the HVAC in the home from get-go (excessive humidity) and our Shea rep has been unable to get Shea's HVAC subcontractor to fully correct the system after several weeks of requests to do so. Very frustrating.
Total Score 3
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 3
Responsiveness 3
Exceptional and Professional
- Phil V.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 28, 2026
- Peoria, AZ
Open communication and honest up front conversations about the home buying and building process
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Professional, friendly, responsive
- Tim S.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 23, 2026
- Bonney Lake, WA
We were kept up to date throughout the building process and they were very transparent on any issues that came up.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Happy with Shea
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 22, 2026
- Wickenburg, AZ
Shea did a great job with the whole home buying process as well as taking care of a few things after we moved in. They stood by the product and were great to work with.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Smooth as well
- Julie H.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 19, 2026
- Ladera Ranch, CA
Too many things to learn
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
High premium for lot.
- Richard K.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 19, 2026
- Littleton, CO
The house was a take back by Shea for someone who was transferred. We did not get to chose or change upgrades that were selected by the first buyer, even though we bought 5 months before the house completion date. Disappointing.
Total Score 4
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 4
Very well coordinated and on time.
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 17, 2026
- Rio Verde, AZ
Keep doing what you are doing.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Acceptable
- Jeffrey R.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 17, 2026
- Carlsbad, CA
I would prefer the fit and finish warranty have more home owner input and intervals than 1 month, 5 months and 1 year.
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 4
Impressive post-sale support
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 13, 2026
- Parker, CO
I didn't expect to receive the ***** of post-sale support as I did. A nice surprise.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Shea Home Purchase
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 12, 2026
- Bonney Lake, WA
The quality of the home as well as the process of buying was excellent.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Quality construction and timely responses to items needing attention.
- Patrick C.
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 11, 2026
- Kuna, ID
The people made the difference. From ***** in sales to *****, Rick & Bill on warranty matters, they all exceeded our expectations. It's been a great home buying experience.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Had a terrible experience
- Anonymous
- Verified Homebuyer
- July 07, 2026
- Parker, CO
Here's a stronger but professional version: We bought a million-dollar home from Shea Homes expecting quality craftsmanship and a smooth experience. Unfortunately, every step of the process has been frustrating. From construction defects to warranty issues, it has been one challenge after another. The construction quality has been far below what you'd expect for a home at this price point, and getting issues resolved has been difficult and time-consuming. This has been a very disappointing experience, and based on what we've gone through, I can no longer recommend Shea Homes to friends or ...
Total Score 1
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 1
Narrow Reviews by Area
Floorplan Name:
saved to favorites!
To see all the homes you’ve saved, visit the My Favorites section of your account.
Floorplan Name:
Home by [BUILDERNAME]
Builder Reviews Total Score in all areas
Here is a list of all the communities where this floor plan is available. Click to see pricing and community information.