Shea Homes Reviews

I had a bad experience and cannot recommend Shea to any new home buyer. There were many delays and the staff were unprofessional. Overall I had a very bad experience with Shea homes and do not recommend them to anyone looking for a timely home buying experience.

Sub par customer care and lack of empathy.

Our experience may be unique, but we did not have a good experience with Shea throughout the buying and build process. It all depends on who you work with in the sales office, the project managers, and how they address issues that arise. Unfortunate given our situation could have been handled very differently with a better outcome.

Shea built us a nice house but after closing the Customer Care disappears ... The overall quality of the house is average. The buying process was good, the choice of external materials and features was terribly poor: only a few samples of bricks and stones, no catalogs to see or images, just use your imagination to try to understand the final result, this is it was very frustrating. The Design Center is a trap for customers, just adding really basic upgrades (or simply changing some materials) the prices rises easily about 20K+. The "included" materials are really ugly. At Closing my front and back garden was not finished and part of the backyard was already dead (it is still dead after 3 months ...). After the first month's inspection I detailed all the haouse issues but after many promises, no one came or called me to fix them. I will not recommend Shea to family and friends. ... More

I don’t recommend to buy from Shea Homes

Project Manager assigned had no clue on the work happening and literally there is no quality check done by Project Manager and Quality team. Not sure why Shea Homes has even employed them. Basics to major issues were missed out. Cracked woods, alignment, Gaps in exterior fly sheets (not stapled and low quality), wavy walls inside, tiles alignment, cracks in concrete. 7 windows needed to be replaces after we pointed out the issue. Our blood boils thinking about what we have been made to go through this. We have spent so many hrs wit observation, documenting and follow up with project manager to get things fixed. All the time we were pushed these will be fixed before delivery. Big liar. In the end when we did escalate to higher up, that level of management is superb awesome but the damage is already done. Like tiles they agreed to replace 90+, but as we had already moved in the home and kids being allergic to dust we could get this corrected and living with these misaligned tiles. ... More

Shea Homes says NO to even any minor change that you ask for, and then turn around and build it for their company people buying homes in the same neighborhood. And this is for a subdivision built by Shea's supposedly upscale "Signature" division! They even changed the color of our home from what we contracted for!

Many things to describe

Buying experience is really bad with Shea homes. I booked home directly from builder when I qualified for 2.7% interest but with in 6 months everything changed in economy and interest rate went to 5%. When I asked for some relaxation/discount they weren't helpful or flexible instead they threatened to keep all my 70K deposit. Where as other builders like Pulte gave 20K discount also flexible with closing date to my friend who booked new house around same time. Services is really bad with Shea. They don't even care about customers once they sell the property. Please think twice before buying with Shea homes. They cover themselves in contract they don't think anything about customers. WORST builders to buy home from. Advice, don't go with ads instead do your research before getting into contract. ... More

The process of building our house with Shea Homes was full of stress, frustration and anxiety instead of excitement. The company contracted unqualified workers that didn't care for the work they do. We though the quality of work will be the same as the model home WRONG, before moving in, we had to paint the house, the paint the company used was the lowest quality. We been leaving in the house 2 months and quite often we loss electricity in the master bedroom, we report the problem at least 6 times and still is not fixed, is a long list of problems due to the very poor job.

Bad quality and bad electronic things doors leak and mismatched

The painting and interior work is horrible the cabinets are weak please don’t rush your inspection cause there will be a lot of thing you notice once you settle into your home

Very frustrating that after 2 months of buying a brand new home, Shea still has not done anything about our concrete driveway that is completely stained and dark. They have offered to acid wash it, which they still haven't done. We were told that doesn't work , they may not cover this at all. This is very unacceptable for a home over 3MM, and very disappointing that Shea wouldn't take care of this.

I would recommend against buying a home with Shea. The sold a vision of build quality and then continually made excuses of how the subcontractors in the area were low quality but all they had available for the build in a large city. There were multiple unfinished aspects of the build but when we asked that the complete aspects of the build prior to close they threatened to void our contract and keep our deposit if we didn't keep the planned move in date. Every subcontractor that we've had to bring in to fix things has commented on how absurdly poor the workmanship was and how things were just left unfinished (ex. cabinets weren't completely installed). They try to push all aspects of the unfinished build to after closing so they can be fixed "under warranty" without telling you that means they won't get to it for 6-12 months based on their warranty schedule. Overall, very poor experience with a builder that sells itself on "Shea Quality" only to cut corners at every turn. Use a cheaper builder because Shea uses the same subcontractors as other builders but charges a premium for the same build quality. ... More

Once the house becomes yours, consider yourself lucky if you don't have a silverfish infestation living inside your walls, or a huge amount of ponding in your backyard, or cracks in your stucco or anything else that is significantly wrong, because Shea will not help you.

My husband and I were excited to get the chance to finally purchase our first home, but since we decided to purchase from Shea the experience has gone downhill. First they force you to make choices about any upgrades within weeks with only one visit to a showroom in which the designer does not know the prices of any of the options. You then wait weeks more for pricing and have a few days to make the final choice, giving you no time to choose more options and properly price compare. I recommend not purchasing any of their upgrades and doing it yourself afterward. You'll have more choice, better prices and likely better quality installation by anyone else. The actual builders do a very poor job. We've heard from all our neighbors about issues with their homes. Not only cosmetic problems but showers needing to be demolished and redone, exhaust vents not being connected properly, windows leaking. Our internet router was installed in the ceiling and when they finally came to repair it they said the wires were never connected and since it would be too much hassle for them to fix it they moved it to another part of the ceiling and only covered the previous hole with a white rectangle plastic plate. Not one stretch of baseboard on one wall is actually painted cleanly and white...it looks like they installed the wood flooring after the baseboards and didn't do any touch up. There is paint and extra grout everywhere. It is evident they bang up and damage the wood stair case, door frames and cabinets and just paint over them. Walls are literally wavy and floors are so uneven that bookshelves and furniture that were fine in our old condo are now wobbling when placed on the floor. When they make a mistake they do not admit it, such as how they installed the wrong countertops in our kitchen. The construction manager and others rudely walked into our house when I was there with an inspector, did not introduce themselves and talked so loudly that I had to go outside to hear the inspector speak. They immediately said the countertop was polished (which is what we chose but not what they installed) instead of matte without even turning on the light or examining it properly as we had compared it to two samples of the two finishes to demonstrate how it was the wrong one. Thank god the designer came later and verified it was the matte finish. Every time they fix one minor thing like a closet door off the track, they would bang up the door and just slap on some paint to cover up the damage, only after we'd point out the new damage. There are countless issues that have caused me to have to stay at home during work hours for multiple appointments for people to come evaluate and fix the builder's mistakes. Everyone I have dealt with liken the actual cabinet company and other third parties that come for repairs has been much more of a pleasure to work with and obviously have some level of pride in their work and care for the products. Many have shook their heads and pointed out the carelessness by the builder when reviewing the damange. Another significant issue is our refrigerator has NEVER WORKED! In our walk through we noticed the freezer was leaking. Though the construction manager first admitted he saw the same water drops I was looking at he later kept saying via email that he did not see water in subsequent visits. I had to take pictures to prove it was reoccuring. They refused to fix it and just put in a service request with GE. This should have been fixed before we closed, but Shea took advantage that our interest rate would be expiring (because they delayed our closing over a month) and we could not refuse to close until after the refrigerator was repaired. We closed on January 18, 2023, but the refrigerator still does not work and Shea refuses to replace it. They keep making us fight with GE which has already come out for seven visits to fix multiple issues with the refrigerator. Not only does the freezer still leak despite the GE Tech "fixing" the seal, but the entire refrigerator freezes everything, you cannot use the water dispenser or put anything in the refrigerator section. We already replaced the motherboard and are currently waiting for two new refrigerator doors and other parts that are backordered because GE refuses to be accountable as does Shea. This is corporate greed and unequal bargaining power in action. Shea took advantage of us and refused to provide a working refrigerator by closing. Since they have been aware of the issue for OVER FOUR MONTHS, their only remedy has been to give us one mini refrigerator and make jokes about how they need to charge us for calling them about our refrigerator continously failing to work since we closed on the house despite the fact they knew it leaked before we closed. My husband and I both work very stressful and demanding jobs that require more than full time work. We have a toddler and are expecting another baby in late June. The stress and waste of our precious time that this has caused is ridiculous and should not be happening. Now I have to worry about how I will store breast milk for my baby and am unable to food prep or store enough fresh food for my family because Shea will not take responsibility. Despite the fact I do not have time, I now have to review our contract which we were only given 24 hours on a weekday to sign during the purchase process (and its 100s of pages long) to determine if they have breached the contract since they delivered a house with a known nonfunctioning appliance. We did not spend over 1.6 million for such a subpar quality home and I recommend no one else invest in a Shea home. When the timing is right and we can afford it, we will be moving. But unfortunately we are stuck here and trying to make the best of it. I will likely be on maternity leave handling a small claims court case as that may be the only thing that will get Shea's attention and have them replace our refrigerator. ... More

This is an extreme disappointment and grief I want to bring into your notice that we are facing each day since we have moved to our new house. There were lot of plumbing/ drainage issues each day at different corners of the house. The delivery of the house came with lot of problems that we did not expect at all with Shea homes. We trusted that home inspections are properly done by Shea at each point especially in plumbing and drainage matters. At this time, in midnight we have called After hour emergencies to get this drainage and plumbing issues resolved. We were at risk of our lives where there was water all over in the jack and Jill bathroom and one of the attached rooms that too underneath the tiles and carpet that we cannot have any control over. In the night, around 11 pm accidentally I went to use the bathroom where I noticed water leaking in jack and Jill bathroom underneath the toilet seat area and bathroom floor tile and it got spread all over underneath the carpet in one of the attached rooms. This was an extremely disastrous for us to have faced such an issue in the middle of the night. It took away my sleep and I woke up my husband to look into it. Our infant sleeps in these rooms, this was not at all okay for us to compromise with the quality and delivery we have got to what we have invested in. Earlier also, we had noticed that bathroom fixtures were not installed properly which we ignored as minor problems and fixed it ourselves but past few days getting each part of the house dismantled and getting it all fixed while residing with an infant is a huge stress for us. I do not know what else to say to show how unhappy we are. We did not expect this kind of work from Shea. We are awake at this time and getting it fixed is so annoying and disturbing for us. I mean do we have to live in fear that something else might come up in future again. Also, there is a structural issue which we have mentioned before closing. The main door is crooked and have gaps which allow the air to pass through. The warranty rep told me to bend your neck and you won’t see the any problem. There are many other issue we mentioned and nothing is getting fixed. Worst experience with Shea homes. ... More

Simple items that require attention since 02/01/23 have not been attended to. Typical approach after a sale is finalized. Would not have bought would I have known. I have discouraged partners interested in the community.

Don't buy from them. Rather buy a 100yr old house than a new one from these people. I guarantee ull have less issues. Only person was excellent was the sales guy and the warranty lady. Kindergartens could build a better house.

A bunch of stuff wrong with the house and I can't get anything fixed.

Terrible experience !! Three months later and still NO OVEN!!

The whole build out process was terrible. The general contractors here are basically sales people and have a made up answer for everything you ask them. We’ve had numerous items that were on our addendum that we pointed out that weren’t there while we did our check ins during the build. Sent our sales rep and GC an email listing out all of those things. GC made up lies saying like our coach lights are wired, they bricked over it and they just need to cut it out. Come back a week later, electricians are at the house installing it and even told us that they were called back out because they weren’t initially told to do that. In addition to other items, they ended up having to add it later and ended up doing a shotty job. Another example is that they missed that we were suppose to have a cut out in our master shower, added later, and spilled white grout in a section of our black stand shower floor, and the GCs excuse was that it’s going to change color because that’s where the water hits the ground.. It was clearly grout and he said professional cleaning will get it out.. lie. So be sure to check your addendum items that you paid for as an “upgrade” also our flooring has paint throughout that won’t come off and the wood flooring has noticeable gaps and said no flooring is perfect and they also have planks with wood putty filing and said it’s the texture… we have engineered wood floors, not real wood. When it’s clearly a damaged piece. GC even admitted that the floor was delayed because they were having issues leveling the floor and had to do it 3 times. They also had our dishwasher on top of the counters and ended up scratching it up, we could clearly see how they pushed the dishwasher off and left a clean straight line scratch that was black. It wasn’t coming off, he told us it was the pattern in the granite.. another lie, they ended up having to get someone out to buff it. Don’t get me started on how long it takes them to send someone out. Warranty hardly answers. I have to constantly follow up. We’ve had issues with electrical since we’ve moved in. They are all nice in person but when it comes to taking action.. silence. We’ve had issues with the doors and the weatherproofing causing bugs to come in, there’s a clear line of sight where light is coming in.. GC tried to say it’s a reflection from the glass on our door.. it’s not, when our warranty person came out she even said there’s clearly a hole. Our side fence is poorly cut our dogs can get out of it. GCs response was put chicken wire there because the slant of our lot they had to cut it like that.. also not true, even shea sales rep saw it and agreed that was bad. It got to the point where we were catching so many mistakes, the GC told us we can’t come check on our house anymore and that he would start locking the door if he had to. He wouldn’t respond to our emails, assuming he didn’t want it in writing, but when my agent would call him he would say he’s working on all fixing all the issues. The quality and overall experience we’ve had with shea has been terrible since we signed our contract. I would never build with them again or recommend anyone to build with them. ... More

They forced me to close the escrow with a combo walk without even frig and with a lots of issues.For ex. I was forced to have upgraded washer/ dryer. During the combo walk, it shows them don't fit the space. As if today, Shea still hasn't fix the problem. This is just one of the examples.

I would never a home again from this builder. The quality of home is substandard and they lied and overcharged. This builder is totally untrustwrothy. The sales agent, Cathy was extremely rude and impolite throughout the process. They have used cheap labor and materials throughout. Community feels like cheap throughout. I wish I could give 0 stars.

Multiple issues with workmanship. Fit and finish is laughable with doors that don't align, cabinets damaged, stucco peeling, paint that doesn't cover, trim that doesn't fit together. Not happy with the oversight or lack thereof by project management.