- New homes
- Shea Homes
- Reviews
Shea Homes Reviews
saved to favorites!
To see all the homes you’ve saved, visit the My Favorites section of your account.
What Homeowners Have to Say About Shea Homes.
Shea Homes has a reputation for building quality new construction homes. Their satisfied homeowners give them an average rating of 4.3 stars for their beautiful floor plans and affordable upgrades, their skilled craftsmanship, and commitment to customer service on each house they build. You can read all of Shea Homes 2139 homeowner reviews to learn why they are the right team to build your new home.
Customer Reviews
Matt was excellent
- Bruce M.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 23, 2026
- San Tan Valley, AZ
Excellent service from everyone on team
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Everything was great!
- Samantha G.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 17, 2026
- Encinitas, CA
Shae was amazing to work with. As a first-time home buyer, the process was made easy, clear, and transparent. Not to mention, my condo is gorgeous. Can't recommend them enough!
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
We love customer service but quality has gone down
- William B.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 17, 2026
- Ventura, CA
It’s so hard to say this but the walls are much thinner and the quality of the products used is less than average. It is not the Grove quality. We really miss having a convenient light switch in the kitchen and that is just a basic item on a builders to do list. We can hear neighbor talking and can feel cold air coming through the walls.
Total Score 4
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Review
- Lillian B.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 17, 2026
- Livermore, CA
Great for all; buying experience, working with the sales representative and all maintenance addressed at 1 month.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Unable to Access Garage….not remedied after 2+ months
- Jason D.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 16, 2026
- Marina, CA
We are unable to access the garage and it requires cutting the corner in the parking area to make our garage, however, if anyone is parked there it is difficult to make the turn into the garage with 1 car and impossible with our 2nd vehicle. Currently the parking spots are being used by non-tenants which fortunately has allowed us to discover this problem… when exiting, we can’t clear the cars from our garage and make the turn if they are sticking out just a hair. I honestly think making it an Emergency parking RED curb area is the only way to go! I noticed that the original Shea maps did ...
Shea Homes responded:
Hi Jason and Lisa, the HOA is currently reviewing and addressing the parking area. Thank you for expressing your concerns.
Total Score 4
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 4
Responsiveness 1
All good except for appliances included
- William B.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 16, 2026
- Marina, CA
The design meets our needs. Our problems have been with appliances; we would have made different choices in that area. The Warranty Team has been great, responding quickly and skillfully.
Total Score 5
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Borgata at San Tan Heights
- Andy W.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 13, 2026
- San Tan Valley, AZ
Mike and Lynda were so very helpful with the buying process, and altho there were a couple issues which arose post close, the team is doing a great job with follow through and getting things done. Love the house!
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Shea is A+
- Steven G.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 11, 2026
- Rio Verde, AZ
Great communication with site supervisor and sales person from start to finish. We would highly recommend Shea for you next home build
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Felt like family
- Steven T.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 10, 2026
- Wickenburg, AZ
Listened to my wants, rather than what they wanted to sell me. Everyone had a welcoming spirit (employees and volunteers). Accommodating even after the sale was made, like the lifestyle was more important than the house.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 4
Responsive to issues and questions
- David W.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 09, 2026
- Marina, CA
Good experience so far, I’ve only been at the home 10 days in the last 21/2 months. Minor improvements would be great I.e. soft close hinges on all cabinet doors, soft closing toilet seats, options for ceiling fans in the living and dining rooms. Little details make a big difference.
Total Score 4
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Steve
- Steve K.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 09, 2026
- Las Vegas, NV
It was such a great process from initial deposit to move-in. Everyone involved, Melba, Vee, Michael, were awesome. We are so happy to be living here.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Kyle was a good PM
- Arthur H.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 09, 2026
- San Tan Valley, AZ
Trust the process! Eventually, they will get it right.
Shea Homes responded:
Thank you, Arthur, we have shared your feedback with our team.
Total Score 3
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 3
Responsiveness 3
Enclave Phase 4: An amazing new Seaside Community
- Anonymous
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 09, 2026
- Seaside, CA
We could not be happier with our new home. Walking into a Brand New Home with our custom finishes and our preferred color pallet has just been amazing. The golf course and ocean views during the day are breathtaking and seeing the Monterey Peninsula lit up at night is really special. In addition the entire team at Shea has been great to work with. It’s not just about building homes for them, they are building a community.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Superior Service from Start to Close of Escrow!
- Robert D.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 05, 2026
- Marina, CA
It doesn't get any better than Josh, Bernadette and Lupita explaining, answering questions, selling, assisting you with paperwork, financial experts, compassionate and professional help through out the buying a Shea Home. You experience World Class treatment from the day you go into the sales office to get information, a brochure, veiw the models or get your keys to your new Shea Home which in my opinion is the best quality product and warranty on the market.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Unsatisfied
- Saleh A.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 04, 2026
- Irvine, CA
Unfortunately, my wife and I are not happy with the home warranty team. Lack of construction experience, lack of understanding the homeowner complaint and understand the mess of customer service. Please see our list of serious problems since day one we moved in. Ready to meet any principal to explain.
Shea Homes responded:
Thank you, Saleh, for your feedback. Our Warranty Manager, Scott will be reaching out to you to follow up.
Total Score 3
Quality 1
Trustworthiness 1
Responsiveness 1
Wonderful Community
- Jose P.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 04, 2026
- Littleton, CO
We recently purchased a spec home from this builder, and the entire experience—from contract to move‑in—was smooth and straightforward. The home’s quality and craftsmanship are excellent, and we feel we received great value. The community itself is beautiful, with miles of trails, scenic foothill views, and a thoughtfully designed layout that makes it a truly enjoyable place to live. The builder’s team was professional, responsive, and consistent in delivering what they promised. They answered questions quickly and made the process feel easy.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
A quick closing! What a blessing!
- Patricia C.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 03, 2026
- Denver, NC
I thoroughly enjoyed the purchase of my new home. I love the house, however I do believe it was a little overpriced. Only a little overpriced for the space I have. My only real disappointment was that Shea only offers a 2 yr. structural warranty. Other home builders offer 10 yrs. My home was considered ready to move in. The follow up to any issues was acceptable; except for an outside vendor who doesn't appear to be too responsive.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Repair
- Rick F.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 03, 2026
- San Tan Valley, AZ
I was very happy with my experience. Charmaine was great. My only issue was the lack of water pressure in my shower from day 1. Shea refused to fix the problem and I had to hire a plumber to address the issue
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 4
RECEIVED NO RESPONSE TO MY PREVIOUS FEEDBACK
- Walter S.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- February 03, 2026
- Denver, NC
No response of any kind was provided after our last feedback. Please don't waste people's time.
Shea Homes responded:
Thank you for reaching out. We apologize for any frustration you may have experienced. We understand the local team has connected with you and is working through the details with you directly.”
Total Score 3
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 2
Responsiveness 1
After so many home purchases this was very pleasant surprise
- Laurie W.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- January 30, 2026
- Las Vegas, NV
Responsiveness and listening are the two words I will use to describe all the people I encountered in my Shea home purchase journey.
Total Score 5
Quality 4
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Smooth and positive!
- Lei Z.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- January 29, 2026
- Irvine, CA
Overall, the home buying experience was smooth and positive. The progress was well organized., and communication was clear and timely. We appreciated the support and guidance throughout each stage, which made the experience reassuring and efficient.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Beware of the invisible ink
- Rhonda N.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- January 29, 2026
- Huntersville, NC
Shea is an excellent home and has beautiful floor plans. However, when making choices and paying for upgrades, make sure you know in detail what you are paying for. If the model shows and upgrade and you “think “ you are paying for that upgrade, that is not the upgrade that you will get. Your upgrade would and can be less than. In addition, pay attention to your lot as that also may be smoke and mirrors. If you are involved with your build, you should have no issues or concerns. Great product however they will explain away any concerns that you have.
Total Score 5
Quality 3
Trustworthiness 3
Responsiveness 4
The best experience at every step!
- David S.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- January 29, 2026
- Ventura, CA
We are Realtors and have just purchased a home in Ventura, CA from Shea. Every person we have dealt with has been exceptional. From Kathy, the amazing sales rep, to Vince, the construction supervisor, to Will, the warranty specialist, the care and responsiveness have been unmatched. The home is beautiful. The community plan is thoughtful and charming. This has been a 10+ experience.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Raymond
- Raymond E.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- January 28, 2026
- Hollister, CA
The quality of the build is excellent. We are very happy with our choice to buy is this community. The sales staff is exceptional and the views around are house are awesome!
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 4
Very good experience with Shea.
- Thomas J.
- Verified HomeBuyer
- January 27, 2026
- Peoria, AZ
Great home buying experience, quality work. Very happy with Shea.
Total Score 5
Quality 5
Trustworthiness 5
Responsiveness 5
Narrow Reviews by Area
Floorplan Name:
saved to favorites!
To see all the homes you’ve saved, visit the My Favorites section of your account.
Floorplan Name:
Home by [BUILDERNAME]
Builder Reviews Total Score in all areas
Here is a list of all the communities where this floor plan is available. Click to see pricing and community information.