Shea Homes Reviews

quality of workmanship was very bad!

Poor customer service and extremely poor responsiveness to home issues.

Horrible customer service, I personally would buy from a different builder in the area if I could do it all over again, I honestly could not believe how awful the Shea customer service team is, including Rich the supposed supervisor.

All charges were not disclosed up front (SID). Didn’t find out about it until signing contract. I was told certain things were included in the HOA which were not. The solar company that I had to sign a contract with filed Chapter 11 Bankruptcy, leaving me in limbo. There were overcharges on documents sent to the loan company. Still waiting to hear back from the HOA management regarding a correction on my account. I will say Frankie went to bat for me regarding building issues. I truly appreciate his willingness to help and make things right for me. Mike has also been great answering any Warrenty questions and responding very quickly. Both Frankie and Mike get 5 stars!!!! ... More

My trust was broken when I was pressured to close versus what needed to be fixed and repaired on buyin a new product. Sad that a Superintendant tells me this is a production home. When I spent $750,000 in upgrades. Not a happy buyer

We had health hardship and wanted to stay with present doctors out of state where we were living and cancel ,before builder had started work on house. They responded with keeping our entire large deposit if we cancelled even though my wife was in a life threatening situation. This was not buyers remorse ,but a rea l health scare.

This experience was awful! The VP Scott was arrogant and does not care about customers. I have asked other Shea home neighbors and they all felt the same! No one addresses problems and did not things seriously. We all spent a lot of money and chose to pick Shea, but we was treated as if we should be grateful to have Shea. That is why Perry has sold more houses in this section than Shea. Customer service is the most important aspect of sales.

Be willing to wait for delays and material delays. Home won't be completed at closing.

will not leave a review. They have trampled my first right amendment to freedom of speech, and threatened to have me arrested if I talk anymore

we were told all the extras were included in the price because of the home was already built. Come to find out nothing was included.. Everything wasn’t add-on. Very frustrated that they showed up with a TV mount saying it was no charge/free. It was part of the house. We didn’t even want or use the TV mount and later looked at our paperwork seeing they charged us $450 for a TV mount we didn’t even want or use. They would not credit me nor would they throw something in that value like a lousy outlet that should’ve been there to begin with. frustrating to say the least

I own a Shea home in the Preserve and its beautiful, very well built, no complaints. About 5 years old now. I decided to build a second home (Villa) and have been very disappointed with the process, they were very rude before closing, and the quality of the workmanship. There are so many things wrong and still waiting to get some of them fixed. The dishwasher didn't work. Instead of replacing it, I had to wait 3 weeks for parts, paint spots all over the floors, crooked light switch, shower leaks, shower pressure low.. If I had it to do over I would not buy again. Dan, the warranty repair person has been great. The WIFI which is included in the HOA was a nightmare to get turned on, and so many of the appliances rely on WIFI, it should be done BEFORE you move in. ... More

This was the worst experience ever. I was told 10-12 month build time, it took 20 months to complete my home. No communication!

Shea Homes purchased a superior parcel at The Phoenician and the subdivision design is spectacular! I wish I could continue with positive praise but I can’t. The lack of integrity from day 1, the poor quality of workmanship, and the ongoing lack of transparency is just the beginning. Building a home should be a happy time, but Shea Homes destroyed that dream.

Need better planning Quality of appliances is bad It’s been 3 months still waiting for microwave.- the one we got is not good and bad quality Fridge is bad - bad quality

It’s been 3 month since closing and we are still waiting on some things to get fixed. Painters specifically never show up between the time period they tell you to wait.

This is in lot 39. We have experienced lots of trouble in the home. The customer rep is great, but home builder quality is very very bad. we will pursue law suite to get some coverage for the price paid

I had a really bad experience with Shea. I was given the wrong information since the beginning, and just went downhill from there. I simply could not trust them. On top of a bad experience, they also had some horrible design choices for this community. It was not on their website, and again try to blame it on the buyer. They tried to sweep any wrongdoing under the rug. I could tell, but they would tell me something different, and this happened at almost every level I dealt with. I did have an amazing experience with the Jr. Rep., who I thought was the only one I could believe.

Because this review is going on a public website, I am limiting the review to a summary statement. Overall, the buying experience was poor, which is a shame because as the home buying market shifts and there are fewer buyers, customer service will be the key to future sales.

Beautiful home design and the price was good to include upgrade prices.. I had to remind construction manager about upgrades.. Who is checking the checker? The painters should be banned from painting.. Floors not floated or not properly floated… Still waiting 3 months for outdoor kitchen refrigerator handle.. Waiting on outdoor kitchen brick repairs.. Took a year 13 months to build home since deposit and watched neighborhoods and others builders closing homes within 6 to 8 months.. Can’t blame COVID-19 on this.. The warranty lady for Shea is correcting what should have been done earlier.. The sales lady was amazing and a buffer but heard she got fired.. ... More

Would never buy a shea home again, worst experience from start to end

Stove vent not working properly, was told to go through manufacturer, total BS Grass full of weeds and landscape full of weeds Not satified

Do not use Shea Mortgage. We dealt with many mess ups and rudeness like they were doing us a favor. No customer service. And no continuity or communication between the sales team, closing team, finance team, customer representative teams. You need to be the project manager for all of them which is surprising given the size of the company.

Beware! Make sure to visit Toll Bros BEFORE looking at a Shea Home

Shea has yet to respond to my requests for repairs. Cracked slab and dangerous debris left in yard

Sales team was great; however, my experience building with this builder has been deeply frustrating and disappointing, particularly given the price point and expectations set at contract signing. From early in the process, I encountered significant project management failures, including repeated errors, missed details, and material deviations from the approved plans and selections. These were not subjective preferences—they were clear inconsistencies with documented drawings, specifications, and contractual agreements that I had to identify myself. When I raised legitimate concerns and requested corrections, the response was troubling. Not only was I met with resistance and deflection, but I was also threatened with contract cancellation for simply holding the builder accountable. The Quality Assurance Manager’s interactions were combative and unprofessional, making an already difficult process unnecessarily adversarial rather than solution-oriented. Post-closing, the experience did not improve. HOA management and oversight following close have also been questionable—further extending the pattern of inadequate management beyond construction itself. Throughout the build, I was repeatedly forced to act as my own quality control to protect a major financial investment. Changes and deviations were often discovered only because I proactively reviewed progress—not because the builder identified or corrected them. For a new-construction home of this scale and cost, I expected: • Competent project oversight • Adherence to approved plans and selections • Professional, respectful quality assurance • Transparent communication • A collaborative approach to resolving issues Unfortunately, that was not my experience. To be clear, the final home itself is beautiful and has received positive feedback from independent inspectors from a structural standpoint. However, that outcome is largely due to my own extensive oversight, documentation, and persistence throughout the build. A favorable end result does not negate the months of unnecessary stress, mismanagement, and adversarial interactions that defined the experience—and it does not improve my overall assessment of the builder’s performance. ... More